Ottoman coin- Is it KM 591 or KM 599? [Resolvido]

I need help identifying this Ottoman 1223(25) coin. I have it narrowed down to KM 591 or KM 599. Specs are: 39 mm, 14.94 g, oblique reeded edge.

According to Numista the KM 591 has a plain edge and no dot at 6:00 on the obverse. This coin has an oblique reeded edge and no dot.

According to Numista the KM 599 has an oblique reeded edge but a dot at 6:00 on the obverse. Again this coin has no dot at 6:00 and an oblique reeded edge.

So this coin doesn’t appear to fit either type exactly. Can someone with experience with Ottoman coins help me pin this identification down? Thanks.

Hello,
I believe it's 591, the one with no dot
best
strato

So the KM 591 exists with an oblique reeded edge as well as a smooth edge? Thanks for the reply.

It's indeed KM# 551 (https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces79638.html) since there's obviously no dot where it should be if it would be KM# 559 (https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces29945.html):



Don't worry about that edge, I think it's a mistake in Numista. Look at the obverse picture on the coin page, that's obviously not a plain edge (picture is turned 90° counter clockwise to have a better view):


You can always ask Tolnomur, the owner of the picture, to verify it's not a plain edge, but I think it's pretty obvious.

Essor Prof:

I was getting hung up on the edge, and I agree with you, it does appear the 591 has a reeded edge from the picture. I hadn't noticed that.

Thank you so much for the reply. Makes sense now.

CitaçãolhillmanBu Osmanlı 1223 (25) sikkesini belirlemek için yardıma ihtiyacım var. 39 mm, 14.94 gr, eğik Tırtıllı kenar:. Bunun 599 Özellikleri olan KM 591 veya KM daralmış olması KM 591 düz bir kenar ve ön yüzde 6:00 bir nokta vardır Numista göre. Bu para bir eğik kamışlı kenar ve hiçbir nokta vardır. KM 599 eğik kamışlı kenar ancak ön yüzde 6:00 bir nokta vardır Numista göre. Yine bu sikke 6:00 ve bir eğik kamışlı kenarında hiçbir nokta vardır. Bu sikke tam ya türüne uygun görünmemektedir Yani. Osmanlı sikkeleri konusunda tecrübeli biri bu kimliği tespit etmeme yardım edebilir mi? Teşekkürler.

Bu yardımcı olur umarım http://xn--babacanktphanesi-qzbb.com/Osmanli/Osmanli_sultan.php?Sultani=%27II.Mahmud%27

​