What I was trying to say is that the mint mark if any was removed by the hole so it could be the 1857 S (82,000 mintage) or the 1857 O (1.2 million) or the 1857 (9.6 million). Maybe a type collector would be interested to fill a 1857 hole but anyone looking for the rare 1857 S obviously wouldn't be interested. Still a nice coin to have.