Coin ID Scanner Stealing Numista Data

15 publicações • visualizado 495 vezes

Esta mensagem tem como objetivo: reportando um erro

Estado: Aberto
Votos positivos: 8
Votos negativos: 0

» Acesso rápido à última publicação

Coin ID Scanner app is stealing Numista pictures (and probably coin descriptions and other information) without permission. Here are five examples of stolen pictures:

 

Numista page:  N#5848

 

Numista page:  N#815

 

Numista page:  N#10053

 

Numista page:  N#61778

 

Numista page (picture has been updated by same member):  1 Cent - Elizabeth II (2nd Portrait; Fine Silver Proof) - Australia – Numista

Based on the included coins, I'd say they copied the database little more than a year ago (first half of 2024).

Just call me Bram

No new swaps for the moment, still too many half-ongoing swaps to clean up!

The same is with Numisquare . com ?(I don't want to add link here).

I checked some Gibraltar and IOM coins and they copied everything some months ago, even with some spelling errors that I made (and later corrected on Numista).

MMowiec

The same is with Numisquare . com ?(I don't want to add link here).

Yup, sure enough:

 

N#226296  and

https://www.numisquare (dot) com/25-drachmai-1887-1897-1093700630.html (also not putting the link in here)

Same images and all (which do require attribution they haven't bothered with). You're also right about it being out of date, I see quite a few pages that I've since changed. Interestingly, their lettering fields don't seem to work (or were never copied over), and on the linked page above, they accidentally copied the signatures from a note from Saudi Arabia. Real quality website right there, hope it gets dealt with quickly.

 

EDIT:

Turns out, they're also removing the watermarks from images, real classy work.

Numista's image, CGB watermark
1000 Drachmai
The Other Site, watermark curiously missing…
"Be kind, rewind."

Numista referee for banknotes from Greece, Crete & the Ionian Islands.

I have noticed that certain banknote images taken from numista have been added to banknote museum, by third parties, though I guess it doesn't matter so much as banknote museum allows us to use their images.

There are coin listings for The Gambia which are not depicted here in Numista.

 

Have a look here;

 

https://www.numisquare.com/catalog/category/view/s/africa/id/231/cat/232/?cat=232_gambia-the&p=19 .

 

Aidan.

Poke @Xavier 

I just noticed this aswell with numisquare, they have just basically copy-pasted every single page that exists on numista.

And even the pictures, without any source.

Interrested in nordic numismatic history, and european history overall.

Always looking for damaged, holed or even unidentifyable coins.

Elvi75

I just noticed this aswell with numisquare, they have just basically copy-pasted every single page that exists on numista.

And even the pictures, without any source.

I just noticed the same, with this website.

Including pages created about 1 month ago.

Some coyrights are sometimes mentioned, though

Example:

N#557954

https://www.numisquare.com/eden-chanson-solophone-concert-paris-75-3750141196.html

 

ALL their french tokens are copy-pasted from Numista.

I am working (for free) for Numista, not for Numisquare. @Xavier 's mind about those data stealers would be appreciated.

Edit: Mistake, deleted.

:)

numisquare mentions its ‘marketplace’ which doesn't seem to exist. 

As long as it is not commercial, I guess it doesn't violate the creative commons share alike rules under which many images are shared. 

 

The site is probably powered by some kind of AI scraper bot. Another soulless copycat website with neither purpose nor worth. 

From typos on it, I think its creators are non-native English speakers.

Yes, it's an AI shit.

Even the structure of the catalogue is copied from Numista.

 

No, they don't respect copyright (the link I gave above is an exception)

example of a © CC-BY-NC-SA

N#456626

https://www.numisquare.com/distributeurs-automatiques-humbert-lyon-69-1161545130.html

 

about © CC-BY-NC-SA

 

They even erased copyrights from the photos that had one! Example:

N#366479

https://www.numisquare.com/10-centimes-chambre-syndicale-des-epiciers-detaillants-dax-40-8154215040.html

 

At least we know: writing “Numista” or our name on the pictures is not a sollution…

Hibernia

As long as it is not commercial, I guess it doesn't violate the creative commons share alike rules under which many images are shared. 

That's not true.  Creative commons lisence require the indication of the source. What is more, when I asked for permission from some website, thay allowed but only for Numista. Not for any other websites which simply steal these photos. Also a lot of photos (I guess most of) are not with CC licenses applied so the copyright is broken.

Meanwhile in real life…

I have a plugin for automatically solving those (so bots will have the same ability if not better ones).

» Política do fórum

O fuso horário usado é UTC+2:00.
O horário atual é 08:55.