Sa'dian sharifs coins? [Resolvido]

17 publicações

» Acesso rápido à última publicação

yvevmax
Ingressou: 23 Mar 2011
Publicações: 282
Publicado: 25 Mai 2019, 01:54 #
Publicado: #
I identified only 2 (1 Abd Allah al Ghalib & 1 Abu al Abbas) of 9 coins that seems to be sa'dian sharifs (Morocco)
Here are 7 silver coins still to be identified:

DiSa3: 14 mm

DiSa4: 14 mm

DiSa5: 15 mm

DiSa6: 14 mm


DiSa7: 12-13 mm

DiSa8: 14 mm



DiSa9: 12-13 mm


Thanks for your help.
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 02:14 #
Publicado: #
#4 Abu Muhammad ‘Abd Allah al-Ghalib 965-981 / 1557-1574, Fès mint
Some of the coins, like yours, have a dash between Abu and Muhammad on the reverse side.
AmerSalmeh
Ingressou: 29 Jul 2014
Publicações: 1688
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 10:29 #
Publicado: #
Citação: "numisquare"​#4 Abu Muhammad ‘Abd Allah al-Ghalib 965-981 / 1557-1574, Fès mint
​Some of the coins, like yours, have a dash between Abu and Muhammad on the reverse side.
​Agreed, from the details visible on the coin, they perfectly match the pic on this one
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces158535.html
Catalog Master Referee & Referee for UAE
https://www.instagram.com/amer.coins
Amer Salmeh
yvevmax
Ingressou: 23 Mar 2011
Publicações: 282
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 12:06 #
Publicado: #
OK, solved for #4 but don't you think that #3 and maybe this new coin (#10) below are also from Abd Allah al Ghalib?


The 2 end lines seem similar, no?
yvevmax
Ingressou: 23 Mar 2011
Publicações: 282
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 20:57 #
Publicado: #
Again this small silver coin, bought in Morocco, a bit strange
Diameter is 14 mm and thiner than the other ones.
On one side you can see a 5-pointed star in the middle; maybe this coin is not from Morocco?
Sorry, the scan is not very good.


Any idea?
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 22:06 #
Publicado: #
#8 is also from Abu Muhammad 'Abd Allah al-Ghalib 965-981 / 1557-1574. Mint is at the bottom of the second image but I cannot read it.
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 26 Mai 2019, 22:30 #
Publicado: #
#3 is from Ahmad al-Mansur 986-1012 / 1578-1603 (KM uses the name Ahmad II). I do not detect a mint name. Al-Mansur is visible near the top of the second image: المنصور .
AmerSalmeh
Ingressou: 29 Jul 2014
Publicações: 1688
Publicado: 28 Mai 2019, 02:34 #
Publicado: #
Citação: "numisquare"​#8 is also from Abu Muhammad 'Abd Allah al-Ghalib 965-981 / 1557-1574. Mint is at the bottom of the second image but I cannot read it.
​I believe it's same as #4
mint looks same as
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces158535.html
Catalog Master Referee & Referee for UAE
https://www.instagram.com/amer.coins
Amer Salmeh
AmerSalmeh
Ingressou: 29 Jul 2014
Publicações: 1688
Publicado: 28 Mai 2019, 02:37 #
Publicado: #
Citação: "yvevmax"​OK, solved for #4 but don't you think that #3 and maybe this new coin (#10) below are also from Abd Allah al Ghalib?
​
​
​The 2 end lines seem similar, no?
​
​
​Al-Mansur is very visible. centre of left image
المنصور
Catalog Master Referee & Referee for UAE
https://www.instagram.com/amer.coins
Amer Salmeh
yvevmax
Ingressou: 23 Mar 2011
Publicações: 282
Publicado: 30 Mai 2019, 00:42 #
Publicado: #
According to me, #5 seems to be Abd Allah al Ghalil.
To resume:
#3 & #10: Al Mansur
#4, #5, #8: Abd Allah al Ghalib with #4 from Fes.

So I 'll condider this post nearly solved and I will ask to close it.

In fact, it remains #6, #7 & #9....I'll check on the French Forum, any idea for these 3 coins...
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 1 Jun 2019, 04:01 #
Publicado: #
#6 is from Muhammad al-Mutawakkil 891-894 / 1574-1576.
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 1 Jun 2019, 14:44 #
Editado: 1 Jun 2019, 14:46
Publicado: #
Editado:

Dirham of the Sa’dian ruler Muhammad al-Mutawakkil 891-894 / 1574-1576.

Galal, Naiera Rafik: The Inscriptions on the movable monuments of Morocco during the reign of the Sa'dian sharfs 916-1069 A.H 1510-1659 AD : an archaeological comparative study. Cairo 2010. Coin #84.
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 1 Jun 2019, 23:16 #
Editado: 1 Jun 2019, 23:17
Publicado: #
Editado:
#7
Try Sa’dian ruler Ahmad b.Mahammad 1578-1604


#7 from above //////////////////// ANS 1921.54.1515
yvevmax
Ingressou: 23 Mar 2011
Publicações: 282
Publicado: 2 Jun 2019, 00:48 #
Publicado: #
Great thanks numisquare for your time; I think that these two last coins were not so easy to find.
As far I know, according to the mentionned dates: "Ahmad b.Mahammad" is also known as Abu l' Abbas Ahmad, Ahmed el-Mansour. I have other coins where it is mentionned El Mansour.
Status alterado para Resolvido (yvevmax, 2 Jun 2019, 00:49)
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 2 Jun 2019, 00:54 #
Publicado: #
Thanks. Ahmad el-Mansour is the name in the legend on the coin.
Quant-Geek
Ingressou: 18 Jan 2018
Publicações: 637
Publicado: 7 Abr 2026, 16:29 #
Publicado: #

numisquare
Dirham of the Sa’dian ruler Muhammad al-Mutawakkil 891-894 / 1574-1576.

Galal, Naiera Rafik: The Inscriptions on the movable monuments of Morocco during the reign of the Sa'dian sharfs 916-1069 A.H 1510-1659 AD : an archaeological comparative study. Cairo 2010. Coin #84.

@numisquare Any possibility of getting that paper? Seems to be impossible to find and it is the only authority on these types of coins.

A gallery of my coins and artifacts can been seen on FORVM Ancient Coins
numisquare
Ingressou: 25 Out 2017
Publicações: 600
Publicado: 8 Abr 2026, 02:47 #
Publicado: #

The author of the Ph.D. dissertation is now writing a catalog on the coins of the Sa'dian Dynasty. It is about 60% finished. It will include 500+ varieties and data from about 2200 examples.

Responder
Fórum »

» Política do fórum

O fuso horário usado é UTC+2:00.
O horário atual é 03:00.